# Evidence tier

> An evidence tier says how strong the proof behind an audited number is: rules only, judge-confirmed, or confirmed by the customer or the customer's records.

Published 2026-11-12 · Reviewed 2026-11-12. Canonical: https://attify.app/glossary/evidence-tier

An evidence tier states how strong the proof behind an audited number is. Every audited number Attify publishes names its tier, because "passed the rules on the records" and "confirmed by the customer" are different claims, even when the rate happens to be the same.

## Tiers per standard

From weakest to strongest:

| Standard | Rules tier | Judge-confirmed | Strongest |
|---|---|---|---|
| [Support resolution](https://attify.app/standards/support-resolution#evidence-tiers) | Repeat contact only: no repeat contact in 7 days, no keyword handoff | The judge confirms the issue was resolved | Customer-confirmed: the customer answered that the issue was resolved |
| [Sales meetings](https://attify.app/standards/sales-meetings#evidence-tiers) | Records only: the rule checks its claimed unit counts, (a) to (c) for meetings booked or (a) to (e) for meetings held, on the CRM and calendar | The judge confirms it was a sales meeting with a potential buyer | Qualified: an opportunity followed within 30 days (never the headline) |
| [Bookings](https://attify.app/standards/bookings#evidence-tiers) | Records only: the rule checks its claimed unit counts, (a) to (c) for appointments booked or (a) to (e) for appointments kept, on the booking system | The judge confirms the appointment matches what was agreed | Visit confirmed: a recorded visit (checked in, seated, completed, paid) |

## Rules for reading tiers

- The **headline** is the judge-confirmed tier when the data holds the conversations; otherwise the rules tier, labelled.
- The rules and judge-confirmed tiers share one denominator, so they can be compared directly.
- The strongest tier covers only claims where its evidence exists, and is reported with its coverage (for example, how many claims had an explicit customer answer). It is never extrapolated to the rest.
- Satisfaction ratings never count as customer confirmation ([why](https://attify.app/glossary/customer-confirmed-vs-satisfaction)).
- The [Attify Index](https://attify.app/index/methodology) pools companies on the rules tier only, because the judge samples per company.

Evidence tier goes with [data provenance](https://attify.app/glossary/data-provenance): one says how strong the check is, the other where the data came from. Both appear next to every number.

## Questions

### Which tier is the headline number?

The judge-confirmed tier, when the data holds the conversations. Where no conversation exists for a judge to read, the headline stops at the rules tier and says so.

### Is a higher tier always better?

It is stronger evidence for the claims it covers. The customer-confirmed tier, for example, covers only claims where the customer answered, so it is reported with its coverage and never extrapolated.

## Sources

- Attify: [Attify Audited Resolution Standard v0.11: Evidence tiers](https://attify.app/standards/support-resolution#evidence-tiers), read 2026-11-09
- Attify: [Attify Audited Meeting Standard v0.6: Evidence tiers](https://attify.app/standards/sales-meetings#evidence-tiers), read 2026-11-09
- Attify: [Attify Audited Booking Standard v0.6: Evidence tiers](https://attify.app/standards/bookings#evidence-tiers), read 2026-11-09
